{"slug":"jonathan-maula-interview","title":"Jonathan Maula: 'Everybody views risk differently'","description":"Jonathan Maula, chief investment officer of Castle Hill Capital, on moving from prop trading to wealth management, market sentiment, and how people view risk.","category":"Pilot interviews","publishedAt":"2026-11-11","updatedAt":"2026-11-16","author":"Autopilot","url":"https://start.joinautopilot.com/journal/jonathan-maula-interview","markdown":"https://start.joinautopilot.com/journal/jonathan-maula-interview.md","agent":"https://start.joinautopilot.com/journal/jonathan-maula-interview/agent","contentText":"Jonathan Maula is the chief investment officer and owner of Castle Hill Capital, a family wealth management firm in Virginia. Jonathan started out as a prop trader in New York City, one of ten people hired at a firm where only two remained after six months, before moving into wealth management for a retiring family office manager in Pennsylvania.\n\nOpen it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=jonathan-maula-interview&af_sub1=intro\n\nOn Autopilot, Jonathan publishes Fair Value Fortress. We talked about the jump from prop trading to long-term investing, reading market sentiment alongside the numbers, the difference between a real value opportunity and a value trap, and why everybody views risk differently.\n\nThis interview comes from the transcript of our conversation with Jonathan Maula in June 2026. It has been edited and condensed.\n\nWho are you, and what's your background?\n\nMy name is Jonathan Maula. I'm the owner of Castle Hill Capital, a family wealth management office. We serve mostly everyday families, not big institutions, not big banks or anything like that. I graduated during the great financial crisis, and it was not a fun time to graduate with a finance degree. I always grew up wanting to work on Wall Street, and those jobs were pretty much non-existent when I graduated, so the only thing I could do at that time was prop trade. I came to New York City for a firm, and it started with ten people, and after six months there were only two of us left. Very, very competitive industry. I did that for a few years, and it was cutthroat, to say the least. It's a very lonely profession as well. When you're prop trading, you're just trading a firm's capital, and you don't really get to see the impact it has on everyday people.\n\nWhat is prop trading, and why do people trade on such short time horizons?\n\nNormally you're trading the firm's capital, and it's really short term based. They don't let you hold positions overnight, usually, or more than a few days. The shorter the time frame you trade on, the more random price tends to be, and the more perfect you have to be. You can be right about an investment idea on a week time frame, but wrong on that day. A lot of young people especially get sucked into it, because it's quick, fast money, and everybody wants instant gratification these days. Holding for a longer period of time kind of gets lost, especially on the younger generation.\n\nWhat did you learn from the family office manager you went to work for in Pennsylvania?\n\nThis old man was a CPA, and he ended up managing money for a really wealthy family. It was eye opening, because he would show me things in the accounting world that you're not really looking at all the time when you're going deep into these 10-Ks. He would uncover things you couldn't see just from a financial statement or from data, things the management team was talking about that they were going to do next year, how they were managing their business and their capital. He was super early, super focused on the management team, what the business is doing and how they're operating, whereas in prop trading you're just reacting to price constantly.\n\nHow do you build conviction for a stock now?\n\nWe'll use the data just like everybody else, in terms of finding a stock or building a position. But then we'll really look for sentiment. Everybody's talking about some of these names, and you'll say, okay, that's the one everyone's chasing right now. And just the opposite, when things are really bad and not doing great, I'll use that as a gauge to say, maybe this is the time to take a look. Sentiment with Reddit and social media like Twitter, where retail traders have really started to stick it to institutions, they can drive a stock to crazy prices in both directions, and they'll sell on panic or buy in panic. That's kind of the area right now where you can take advantage of mispricing, because the data is there, the numbers are the numbers, and you just have to see through that panic and that euphoria to make a clear decision on what's in front of you.\n\nWhat separates an undervalued growth stock from a value trap?\n\nThat's the hard part. Blockbuster was growing sales the same as Netflix was growing sales, and the stock was trading lower. Investors were right, it was a value trap. It looked cheap. That's really hard, and I think that's where certain managers add value, figuring out that value trap, or figuring out it's undervalued. There is no right answer. You don't know until a year, two years, three years later, and I don't think there's any magic formula or data set that can tell you that.\n\nHow does money flowing into index funds affect which stocks get bought?\n\nModel portfolios, specifically index portfolios, are largely market cap weighted. If a name is high in market cap and people are funneling their 401(k) money into a model portfolio or index fund, it just continues, continually keeps buying these big names. It feeds the machine, so to speak. We used to seek out smaller companies that were doing really well, but nobody cares, and index funds don't even buy them, because they just continually add to the top market cap weighted companies. Those smaller names really need a big catalyst to get investor interest going. It's good for most people, because they don't want to do the work, they don't want to pick stocks. But it can create an overweight to these big companies, and a lot of the smaller ones that are doing well just get left behind, until somebody wakes up and acquires them, or they make a splash in the news.\n\nEditor's note: that concentration point is about large-cap weights. A large-cap index can leave smaller companies out. A small-cap index fund, such as one tracking the S&P SmallCap 600, and a total-market index fund can own them.\n\nWhat's the most interesting thing you've learned as a wealth manager?\n\nProbably one of the most interesting things I've learned as a wealth manager is that everybody views risk differently. Somebody will walk into my office and say the market's hot, just get me into stocks. Anybody can go buy stocks, you can go buy a growth fund. Then the second there's a pullback, they're calling and saying get me out, I can't handle it. As a wealth manager, your job is to really figure out how much risk people can handle. They'll tell you one thing, they'll say they can handle it, but until they actually see the number on the screen drop, they don't really know. Sometimes they're insistent, sometimes they're just like, I want it, get me in, my neighbor's talking about it, my barber's talking about it, I just want in the stock market. And then sure enough, they're calling a week later saying get me out. So diagnosing risk for an individual is probably one of the greatest skills I've learned in wealth management. It's the same thing with a company almost, trying to figure out how much risk you're willing to take as an investor when you're allocating to a stock.\n\nWhat made you decide to publish Fair Value Fortress on Autopilot?\n\nI've thought about it for so long, that there should be a product like this. Democratizing this sort of access is ideal. I think the concept is really cool, and it's probably the biggest reason I joined Autopilot.\n\nWhy does the relationship between you and the people following your Portfolio matter?\n\nA lot of people could just buy an index fund, but we operate strictly on referrals, and the whole industry of wealth management is built on trust, putting a name to the face. If there's content, if they start to understand the thought process behind that investor, why he's buying this stock, why he's doing this when there's a drawdown, that investor is going to say, this still makes sense to me, his rationale for buying this or getting rid of that still makes sense to me, I believe in it long term. They're more likely to stick with that portfolio, whereas if it's just numbers and that's it, it becomes flimsy. They're getting in at the wrong time, they're getting out at the wrong time.\n\n\"Everybody views risk differently. The second there's a pullback, they're calling and saying get me out.\"\n\nFollow Jonathan Maula's Portfolios on Autopilot\n\nJonathan Maula publishes Fair Value Fortress on Autopilot, an investing app that lets you follow Portfolios from investors, AI models, and public filings in your own brokerage account. See Jonathan Maula's Pilot page. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=jonathan-maula-interview&af_sub1=body\n\n- You follow in the brokerage account you already have, and the money stays there.\n- On Premium Tier, when a Portfolio changes, Autopilot Advisers sends the orders to your broker. On Basic Tier you get an alert.\n- Review the Portfolio's method, holdings and any available performance record before following it. New Portfolios show return figures after 30 days.\n- The Pilot sets the subscription price, there is a 0.00% AUM fee, and you allocate at least $500.\n\nYou are never trading at the same moment as the Pilot, and your account won't match the Portfolio exactly.\n\nOpen it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=jonathan-maula-interview&af_sub1=end\n\n\"Autopilot\" refers to Autopilot Holdings Corp and Autopilot Advisers, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. Fair Value Fortress is managed by Jonathan Maula of Castle Hill Capital, an independent Third-Party Pilot unaffiliated with Autopilot. Autopilot doesn't manage, validate, or guarantee this Pilot's portfolio. This interview reflects Jonathan's own views as of June 2026, edited and condensed, and isn't a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to follow any Portfolio. Individual stocks shown are illustrative and not a recommendation. Concentrated and thematic strategies carry heightened risk of loss. Investing carries risk-including possible loss of principal-and past performance is not indicative of future results. Figures current as of 10/09/26. View our Customer Relationship Summary and other important info at joinautopilot.com/disclaimer.\n\nPortfolios and pilots mentioned in this article:\nJonathan Maula: https://start.joinautopilot.com/strategies/pilots/jonathan-maula-4698\n1 public portfolio."}