Pilot interviews

Peter Cline on value, catalysts and defense

Peter Cline of Cline Cap, a former infantryman and M\&A professional, on fundamentals-first investing, catalysts, value traps, and a long/short Portfolio.

Autopilot10 min read

Peter Cline got into investing by reading books about disaster, like Too Big to Fail and When Genius Failed. Peter enlisted in the Army right out of high school and served as an infantryman, then worked in strategy consulting and in mergers and acquisitions. About two years before our conversation, Peter left M&A to start a recruiting company that focuses on technical talent for defense.

Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=peter-cline-interview&af_sub1=intro

On Autopilot, Peter publishes All-Weather Alpha under the name Cline Cap. In June 2026, Peter described All-Weather Alpha as a long/short strategy: a hedge against the Nasdaq 100, with the rest in a few companies that Peter sees trading below fair value, ideally with a clear event that could close the gap. Portfolios on Autopilot hold only stocks and ETFs, so a hedge like this is held through an ETF designed to move opposite the index.

This interview comes from the transcript of our conversation with Peter Cline in June 2026. It has been edited and condensed.

How did you get started investing?

I started investing almost 10 years ago now, by reading a bunch of books, but basically all books about disaster. So think Too Big to Fail, When Genius Failed. And so, notably, calamity is what inspired me into investing.

From there, I started personally investing and then started a career in strategy consulting and in mergers and acquisitions. And that laid the foundation for my investing philosophy, which is very fundamental, based on looking at the financial statements and the earning power of the business and looking for some margin of safety.

What was your time in the Army like?

Before I went into strategy consulting, I was in the Army. I was an infantryman. I enlisted right out of high school. It takes a very low ASVAB, or the military IQ test score, to become an infantryman, which is funny, because I took the ASVAB and did decently well. So my recruiter's like, you should go repair rockets or do something that sets you up long term. And I was like, I want to be an infantryman and go carry a rifle and wear a heavy backpack and kick doors. And I am so happy I did, because it was great.

In the military, I got to lead a team of soldiers, and I competed in all these competitions. The biggest one was the Fort Benning Non-Commissioned Officer of the Year. And I won that right before I was getting out of the military, which I was very proud of. But as I got out, I was then going to work in finance roles, and I was telling investment banking recruiters or consulting recruiters, like, I just won the Fort Benning Non-Commissioned Officer of the Year. Nobody cared.

What did you pick up during your time in M&A?

I think one of the biggest things is that value is very subjective. Very often, within a business, you'll find component parts that are extremely valuable. M&A as a whole gets you to break a business down into each revenue line and each revenue model of how they're actually making money, and to look at, can you value each of those separately and do a sum of the parts analysis, or can you do the breakup value? And in doing that, can you arrive at some different conclusion or find some way that you can create value?

How does judging talent all day change how you evaluate a company?

The current role I'm in now, being able to staff some of the most interesting defense companies, definitely gives a very good point of view, and it's like, where the good tech is, where the good engineers want to work. I think that is one of the most telling things for a business: can you attract the people who are going to ultimately build the product? And so I think that has definitely informed my defense investing, of which technologies actually matter and which are just smoke in the air that aren't going to do anything.

How did a decade of investing turn into launching a Portfolio on Autopilot?

I think the timing was right. I definitely paid my tuition to the market to learn. For the first few years, I was trading all kinds of different products and all kinds of different strategies and losing money. And so I think initially, me honing my own way of trading was important.

But it was never something I would have done while working full time at M&A. It's just challenging to balance, and I doubt compliance would love it. But post-leaving M&A, especially now that I'm running my own company, I also still want this connection to the market, because I'm still spending so much time doing research. I realized that it just makes a ton of sense now to dive in and continue it.

For someone who has no idea what "fundamentals first" means, what are you actually looking at?

I would say it's looking at the financial statements of the business in the context of the broader market that they're in. The first thing you're going to look at is the free cash flow that the business can produce. You want to look and see, is this a business that is producing cash flow in a way that is sustainable and defensible? That first is the earning power of the business, and it's producing cash flow that is trading in such a way relative to its peers in the market that it is relatively cheap.

What's the biggest mistake retail investors make that an acquirer never would?

I think they blindly let a trend inform them, and they fall in one of two camps. I think it is either, this stock has gone up this year, I want to be part of the party, I'm going to buy it, which can be disastrous. Or it's like, I'm a contrarian and this stock's down, so I'm going to buy it. But notably, neither of them ever looked at a filing or knows what the company does or how it makes money.

And this isn't only in retail investors. There's a lot of people who buy businesses who have no idea about the market. You have career investment bankers now making large investment decisions in defense, but they have never in their entire lives talked to somebody who's actually fielding that equipment. We saw it when we were doing some of the innovation work in the Army. You'd have some of these contractors come out and they're like, I've designed this radio pack, heads-up display, this, this and this. Okay, how much does it weigh? Like 40 pounds. And you're like, okay, nobody wants it. No soldier wants to carry extra weight, especially not that much, for some very poorly working radio system.

In plain English, what does it mean for All-Weather Alpha to be long and short at the same time?

It means you are both buying stocks and betting that their value will rise, but also selling stocks and betting their value will fall, at the same time. Typically a long short strategy does that to hedge out something.

So for us, we're short the Nasdaq 100 [through an ETF built to move opposite the index]. We were kind of taking out this high-beta market risk, but trying to stay long names that are attractive for some reason other than just the market going up. The rest of it is going to be longs of companies that have one of these two things, which is either a large gap to fair value or some clear event that I think is going to create value for the company, and ideally both of them. So that is the long side: good companies, margin of safety, catalyst to get to their fair value.

How do you avoid a value trap?

Look for a catalyst. There has to be some way that it is going to get to its fair value in the next year, and you need to reassess it again and again and again. The ideal answer is you stack the catalysts, because you can't be sure. When you can stack multiple, that is the goal, because even if one doesn't work out, multiple can.

It is not a buy it and wait for value to come. It's like you buy it and you're every day saying, is this catalyst getting further away? Is it still going to happen? If it happens, would people still care? But even with all that, you can wind up buying one and sitting there for a while. And so you do your best.

Do you ever get caught up in the hype?

I'll admit, at times, I'll get caught in the hype, too. Nobody's perfect. But the vast, vast, vast majority of the trades are very fundamentally focused. And I think the two things that it also instilled: one is do the fundamental research, but two is intellectual honesty, because when you mess up, you can tell.

There's a book called Thinking in Bets that's very popular, by Annie Duke, a very good poker player. That's like, you should not result. You don't think, okay, I made money on this trade, so it was a good trade. You think, what was my thought process going into it? Was I poorly informed making the trade? Because if I was, even if I made money, it doesn't really matter. If I do that again and again, I'm not going to be profitable in the long run. So that's one thing: the continuous improvement of, okay, that trade didn't work, I need to stop doing that, which is ongoing.

If someone follows All-Weather Alpha, what are they betting on?

They're betting that value will prevail. I think that is the biggest thing. The short portion [an ETF built to move opposite the index] is there, but more so it is hedging out market exposure and kind of some of the high-beta nature of a few of those names. Really, the biggest thing is you're betting that these undervalued companies can get to fair value.

“"I definitely paid my tuition to the market to learn."”

Follow Peter Cline's Portfolios on Autopilot

Peter publishes All-Weather Alpha on Autopilot (Peter Cline's Pilot page), an investing app that lets you follow Portfolios from investors, AI models, and public filings in your own brokerage account. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=peter-cline-interview&af_sub1=body

  • You follow in the brokerage account you already have, and the money stays there.
  • On Premium Tier, when the Portfolio changes, Autopilot Advisers sends the orders to your broker. On Basic Tier you get an alert.
  • Review the Portfolio's method, holdings and any available performance record before following it. New Portfolios show return figures after 30 days.
  • The Pilot sets the subscription price, there's a 0.00% AUM fee, and you allocate at least $500.

You're never trading at the same moment as the Pilot, and your account won't match the Portfolio exactly.

Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=peter-cline-interview&af_sub1=end

"Autopilot" refers to Autopilot Holdings Corp and Autopilot Advisers, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. All-Weather Alpha is managed by Cline Cap, an independent Third-Party Pilot unaffiliated with Autopilot. Autopilot doesn't manage, validate, or guarantee this Pilot's portfolio. This interview reflects Peter's own views as of June 2026, edited and condensed, and isn't a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to follow any Portfolio. Concentrated and thematic strategies carry heightened risk of loss. Leveraged and inverse exchange-traded funds are complex products that generally reset daily and can lose value over time, including when the market moves in the direction anticipated; they may not be suitable for most investors. Investing carries risk-including possible loss of principal-and past performance is not indicative of future results. Figures current as of 10/09/26. View our Customer Relationship Summary and other important info at joinautopilot.com/disclaimer.