Guides
Robo-advisor alternatives: index funds, an advisor, or following a Portfolio
Robo-advisor alternatives: index funds, a financial advisor, or Autopilot, where you pick a Portfolio and follow it in your own brokerage. How each works.
I'm Chris, one of the co-founders of Autopilot.
Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=robo-advisor-alternatives&af_sub1=intro
Short answer: the main alternatives to a robo-advisor are picking index funds yourself in a brokerage account, hiring a financial advisor, or following someone else's Portfolio. A robo-advisor builds a mix for you from a questionnaire. The alternatives change who picks the investments, where the money sits, or how you pay. On Autopilot you choose the investor, filing, or AI model, the Portfolio runs in your own brokerage account, and Premium Tier is a flat subscription with a 0.00% AUM fee. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=robo-advisor-alternatives&af_sub1=body
Let me explain.
Autopilot is an investing app that lets you follow Portfolios from investors, AI models, and public filings in your own brokerage account.
1) The alternative I know best
I helped build Autopilot, so I know this one inside out, and you should read what I say about it with that in mind. The idea is simple. Instead of an algorithm handing you a mix, you pick a Portfolio, and it runs in a brokerage account you already own. Here's what I'd weigh if I were leaving a robo-advisor:
- Your account stays put. You connect the brokerage you already use, and Autopilot can't move or withdraw what's in it.
- You can check the record first. There were 391 live Portfolios as of October 8, 2026, and each shows any available performance record. New Portfolios show return figures after 30 days.
- The fee is flat. Premium Tier charges a subscription for each Pilot with a 0.00% AUM fee, and Basic Tier carries no Autopilot fee.
Three Portfolios I'd point you to if you want to see how the choices differ:
- Buffett Tracker is built around Warren Buffett's long-term, buy-and-hold style.
- Citadel Tracker is a hedge fund Portfolio, based on Citadel, the firm Ken Griffin runs.
- AI Portfolios have an AI model generate the picks, with a Pilot reviewing and implementing the changes.
2) What a robo-advisor is
Investor.gov says the term "robo-adviser" generally refers to an automated digital investment advisory program. In most cases, you complete an online questionnaire about your goals, time horizon, income, and risk tolerance. Based on your answers, the program creates and manages a portfolio for you. Investor.gov says many robo-advisers use ETFs, that they often seek to offer lower costs and fees than traditional advisory programs, and that some require lower account minimums.
So the robo-advisor picks. You supply the answers. Where the money is held depends on the company, so ask each one.
If that's what you want, it's a reasonable fit. The rest of this page is for everyone else.
3) How six robo-style apps charge, as of November 10, 2026
Here's what each company publishes on its own pricing page. I've left out anything a page didn't state.
- Betterment: $5 a month on balances under $24,000, or 0.25% a year if you set up $200 or more in monthly recurring deposits or reach $24,000. Its Premium plan is 0.65% a year with a $100,000 minimum and access to an advisor.
- Wealthfront: a 0.25% annual advisory fee for The Wealthfront Portfolio. Its investing page says you can start with as little as $500.
- Acorns: three monthly plans, $4, $8, and $12.
- Stash: The Stash Plan is $12 a month, or $108 billed annually. Smart Portfolios add an advisory fee on top, and Stash's pricing page has the current fee, so look there before you sign up.
- M1 Finance: your portfolio is a Pie made of the stocks and ETFs you choose, which you can build yourself or with M1 Advisor's help. A $3 monthly platform fee is waived if eligible M1 assets reach $10,000 on at least one day of the billing cycle, or with an active M1 Personal Loan.
- SoFi: SoFi offers automated investing accounts. Its pricing page has the current fee, so look there before you sign up.
Investor.gov also says to ask about other costs, for example the management fees on the ETFs bought for your account. Turn each price into dollars a year at your balance.
4) Alternative one: index funds in your own brokerage account
Investor.gov says an index fund is a mutual fund or ETF that seeks to track a market index, such as the S&P 500. It says index funds generally follow a passive style, with less buying and selling, and may be able to save costs. It also says not all index funds cost less than actively managed funds, so check the actual cost.
You choose the funds and you rebalance them. The tradeoff is effort. You do the work a robo-advisor does for you.
5) Alternative two: a financial advisor
Investor.gov says advisers typically give ongoing advice and monitor your investments, and may offer financial planning. The fee is typically based on the value of your account. CFP Board also lists retainers, commissions, fixed fees by service, and hourly rates as common ways to pay a planner. Investor.gov suggests asking any adviser what services they offer, any limits on what they can offer, how much you'd pay, and what conflicts of interest they may have.
6) Alternative three: follow a Portfolio
This is what Autopilot is built for. You choose a Portfolio instead of picking stocks yourself, and it runs in the brokerage account you already have.
Each Portfolio has a Pilot, an investor or a firm. For an AI Portfolio, the model generates the picks, the Pilot reviews and implements Portfolio changes, and Autopilot sends them to client accounts. You connect the brokerage account you already have and allocate at least $500 to a Portfolio. Autopilot Advisers gets limited authority to place trades in that account.
Premium Tier costs $29.99 to $199.99 a quarter or $99.99 to $699.99 a year for each Pilot, as of October 9, 2026. You can browse the Portfolios before you sign up.
7) The options side by side
Who chooses what you own
Robo-advisorAn algorithm, working from your questionnaire answers
Index funds you pickYou
Financial advisorThe advisor, with you
AutopilotYou choose a Portfolio, and the Portfolio's approach sets the holdings
Where the money sits
Robo-advisorVaries by company, so ask
Index funds you pickIn your brokerage account
Financial advisorVaries by firm, so ask
AutopilotIn your brokerage account, since Autopilot doesn't hold client money
What it costs
Robo-advisorA percentage of your balance or a subscription, per each company's page
Index funds you pickFund costs, plus any broker costs
Financial advisorCommonly a percentage of assets, hourly, flat, or commissions
AutopilotNo Autopilot fee on Basic Tier; a flat subscription per Pilot on Premium Tier
Minimum to start
Robo-advisorVaries. Betterment lists none for its base price, and Wealthfront says as little as $500
Index funds you pickWhatever your broker and fund require
Financial advisorDepends on the advisor
Autopilot$500 per Portfolio
What's up to you
Robo-advisorYour answers, and sometimes the allocation
Index funds you pickEverything
Financial advisorThe plan, with advice
AutopilotWhich Portfolio, how much, and when to stop
Scroll sideways to see every column.
| Robo-advisor | Index funds you pick | Financial advisor | Autopilot | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who chooses what you own | An algorithm, working from your questionnaire answers | You | The advisor, with you | You choose a Portfolio, and the Portfolio's approach sets the holdings |
| Where the money sits | Varies by company, so ask | In your brokerage account | Varies by firm, so ask | In your brokerage account, since Autopilot doesn't hold client money |
| What it costs | A percentage of your balance or a subscription, per each company's page | Fund costs, plus any broker costs | Commonly a percentage of assets, hourly, flat, or commissions | No Autopilot fee on Basic Tier; a flat subscription per Pilot on Premium Tier |
| Minimum to start | Varies. Betterment lists none for its base price, and Wealthfront says as little as $500 | Whatever your broker and fund require | Depends on the advisor | $500 per Portfolio |
| What's up to you | Your answers, and sometimes the allocation | Everything | The plan, with advice | Which Portfolio, how much, and when to stop |
8) Three questions that narrow it down
How much do you want to decide? If the answer is nothing, a robo-advisor is built for that. If it's everything, index funds in your own account fit. If you want to pick a strategy and leave the stock picking to someone else, a Portfolio fits, and that's Autopilot.
What's your balance? Percentage fees grow with it. Flat subscriptions don't. Turn each price into dollars a year before you compare.
Do you want a person? An advisor is built around that. Investor.gov says some robo-advisers also offer access to an investment professional, and Betterment's Premium plan lists access to an advisor.
Here's who each one fits. A robo-advisor fits if you want one account that builds and manages a mix for you. Index funds fit if you want to choose and manage it yourself. An advisor fits if you want a person. Autopilot fits if you want to pick the strategy, read its chart before you follow, stay in your own brokerage account, and pay a flat price.
9) What to know before you follow a Portfolio
Here's the risk, said plainly. Following a Portfolio isn't a shortcut to getting rich. Pilots can run up gains for years, sit flat for years, or lose money. A Portfolio that holds a handful of individual stocks isn't a diversified mix. The SEC's beginners' guide says four or five individual stocks isn't diversified, and puts the bar at at least a dozen carefully selected stocks.
Expect your account to differ a little from the Portfolio, and expect your orders to land at a different moment than the Portfolio's trades. Trades inside a taxable brokerage account can create taxable gains or losses, so bring a tax professional in. The IRS explains how capital gains and losses are taxed. Spend your time on the person behind the Portfolio, and read the guide to choosing who to follow.
10) If you're ready to try the third option
- Download the Autopilot app.
- Connect an individual or IRA account at Public, Robinhood, eToro, Alpaca, or Charles Schwab. Interactive Brokers is in beta.
- Choose a Portfolio and read its performance chart.
- Allocate at least $500. You have 5 days from your latest charge to cancel for a full refund.
TLDR: The main robo-advisor alternatives are index funds you pick yourself, a financial advisor, or following a Portfolio. A robo-advisor, per Investor.gov, builds a portfolio from your questionnaire answers. Index funds put the choices on you. An advisor adds a person and a fee. On Autopilot you pick a Portfolio that runs in your own brokerage account, with no Autopilot fee on Basic Tier and a flat subscription per Pilot on Premium Tier. The AUM fee is 0.00%. None of these removes risk. What Autopilot adds is the choice of Portfolio, a chart you can read first, and your money staying at your own broker.
Frequently asked questions
Robo-advisor alternatives
The main ones are picking index funds yourself in a brokerage account, hiring a financial advisor, or following a Portfolio. Each changes who decides and how you pay. On Autopilot, you pick a Portfolio and it runs in your own brokerage account. Basic Tier carries no Autopilot fee, and Premium Tier charges a flat subscription for each Pilot with a 0.00% AUM fee, so the price doesn't rise with your balance.
What is a good alternative to a robo-advisor?
It depends on what you want to control. If you want to pick everything, index funds in your own brokerage account. If you want a person and a plan, a financial advisor. If you want to choose a specific strategy and have it run in your account, follow a Portfolio. None of them guarantees a result, and each has costs, so compare the dollars a year at your balance.
Betterment alternatives
Betterment charges $5 a month on balances under $24,000, or 0.25% a year with $200 or more in monthly recurring deposits or at $24,000, as of November 10, 2026. Alternatives include other robo-style apps, index funds you pick yourself, an advisor, or following a Portfolio on Autopilot. They differ in who picks and how you pay, so compare what each publishes.
Wealthfront alternatives
Wealthfront publishes a 0.25% annual advisory fee for The Wealthfront Portfolio, as of November 10, 2026. Alternatives include other robo-style apps, index funds you pick yourself, a financial advisor, or following a Portfolio in your own brokerage account on Autopilot. Autopilot's Premium Tier charges a flat subscription for each Pilot instead of a percentage of your balance, and you can see each Portfolio's performance chart before you follow it.
Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=robo-advisor-alternatives&af_sub1=end
"Autopilot" refers to Autopilot Holdings Corp and Autopilot Advisers, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. Betterment, Wealthfront, Acorns, Stash, M1 Finance, and SoFi are separate companies unaffiliated with Autopilot. Investing carries risk-including possible loss of principal-and past performance is not indicative of future results. Figures current as of 10/09/26. View our Customer Relationship Summary and other important info at joinautopilot.com/disclaimer.
- Month
- +0.16%
- 3 months
- +1.1%
- YTD
- +12.3%
- 1 year
- +12.8%
- Since start
- +87.5%
As of
- Month
- -0.46%
- 3 months
- -1.7%
- YTD
- +13.9%
- 1 year
- +21.5%
- Since start
- +120.0%
As of
The performance data presented reflects the aggregated results of actual client portfolios managed by the Registered Investment Adviser (RIA), based on the trading activity in the securities contained in the relevant portfolio over the specified period. If fewer than 10 clients are invested in the portfolio, the data represents the aggregate performance of all clients following this strategy. Performance figures are shown net of advisory fees, calculated using the applicable subscription fee and an assumed $50,000 account size. Because subscription fees are flat rather than asset-based, accounts smaller than $50,000 would experience a higher effective fee percentage and lower net performance, while larger accounts would experience a lower effective fee percentage. Actual investor outcomes can vary due to factors like brokerage support for fractional shares, account size, trade timing, fees, and taxes, and past performance should not be interpreted as a guarantee of future results or typical of all portfolios.