Guides
Robo-advisor vs. following a Pilot: who decides, what you own, what it costs
Robo-advisor vs. following a Pilot: who picks, where the money sits, and the price. With Autopilot you choose a Portfolio in your own brokerage account.
I'm Chris, one of the co-founders of Autopilot.
Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=robo-advisor-vs-following-a-pilot&af_sub1=intro
Short answer: a robo-advisor builds your mix from a questionnaire and usually charges a percentage of your balance or a subscription. On Autopilot, you pick a Portfolio yourself, it lives in your own brokerage account, and Premium Tier is a flat subscription per Pilot with a 0.00% AUM fee.
Let me explain.
Autopilot is an investing app that lets you follow Portfolios from investors, AI models, and public filings in your own brokerage account. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=robo-advisor-vs-following-a-pilot&af_sub1=body
A Pilot is an investor or firm that publishes a Portfolio on Autopilot. You follow the Portfolio, not the person's personal trades.
1) What following a Pilot actually gets you
- You pick the strategy. It can be an investor, a hedge fund's public filing, or an AI model, and there were 391 live Portfolios to look through as of October 8, 2026.
- Your brokerage account stays home base. Autopilot can't move or withdraw anything from it, and if you cancel, your stocks are still sitting there.
- You can read the record before you commit. Review a Portfolio's method, holdings and any available performance record before following it. New Portfolios show return figures after 30 days.
- The price is a number you can plan around. Premium Tier is a flat subscription per Pilot with a 0.00% AUM fee, so a bigger balance doesn't mean a bigger bill. Autopilot charges no fee on Basic Tier.
- Starting small is fine: $500 per Portfolio, and a full refund if you cancel within 5 days of your most recent charge.
To see the range, here are examples available on Autopilot:
- Buffett Tracker: the model is Warren Buffett's long-term, buy-and-hold approach.
- Citadel Tracker: draws on the strategies of Citadel, the hedge fund Kenneth Griffin runs.
- AI Portfolios: independent Pilots, including Dr. Lira's AI Finance Labs and Rallies, publish these. GPT, Claude, and Gemini generate the picks. The Pilot's subscription and included Portfolios are shown in the app.
2) Who decides what you hold
Investor.gov says that in most cases a robo-adviser has you complete an online questionnaire about your goals, time horizon, income, and risk tolerance. Based on that, it creates and manages a portfolio for you. It adds that the recommendation is limited by the information the robo-adviser asks for and receives from you.
So a robo-advisor decides from your answers. The mix is built around you.
On Autopilot, you decide first. You choose a Portfolio, and its method sets what it holds: an investor's picks, an AI model, or public filings. Autopilot doesn't design these Portfolios. Pilots do. For an AI Portfolio, the model generates the picks, the Pilot reviews and implements Portfolio changes, and Autopilot sends them to client accounts. Autopilot Advisers, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser, sends the orders to your account.
3) What you own
Investor.gov says many robo-advisers use ETFs, and some focus on just a limited range of products, such as broad-based ETFs. So the mix is often built from ETFs, which are funds that hold many securities.
A Portfolio can hold something very different, such as a set of individual stocks. The SEC's beginners' guide says four or five individual stocks isn't diversified, and puts the bar at at least a dozen carefully selected stocks. A total stock market index fund, it says, owns stock in thousands of companies.
That's the concentration tradeoff. A more concentrated Portfolio depends more on each holding than a broad fund mix does. Read each Portfolio's holdings before you follow it. A Portfolio shows any available performance record. New Portfolios show return figures after 30 days. A chart shows history. It doesn't promise anything.
4) Where the money sits
With a robo-advisor, where your money is held varies from company to company. Ask each one where yours would sit.
On Autopilot, your money never leaves the brokerage account you already have. You give Autopilot Advisers limited authority to place trades there, and Autopilot doesn't hold client money. The brokerage holds the account, fills the orders, and sends your statements and tax documents. Orders can go out in batches over the trading day, and low liquidity, trading halts, or technical problems can delay them. Canceling a subscription doesn't sell anything, so whatever you hold is still yours afterward.
The brokers that work today are Public, Robinhood, eToro, Alpaca, and Charles Schwab, with Interactive Brokers in beta.
5) What it costs, as of November 10, 2026
Each company publishes its own price, and they use different units.
- Wealthfront says its advisory fee for The Wealthfront Portfolio is 0.25% annually.
- Betterment says $5 a month for investing accounts, or 0.25% annually with $200 or more in monthly recurring deposits or a balance of $24,000 or more.
- Stash says The Stash Plan is $12 a month. Smart Portfolios add an advisory fee, so look up the current number on Stash's pricing page before you sign up.
Fund fees come on top. Investor.gov's advice is to ask what other costs you'd pay, such as management fees on the ETFs bought for your account.
Here's Autopilot's side, as of October 9, 2026. Basic Tier carries no Autopilot fee. On Premium Tier you pay each Pilot a flat subscription, $29.99 to $199.99 a quarter or $99.99 to $699.99 a year, and a subscription covers the Portfolios included in that Pilot's plan. Check the app for the included Portfolios and current price. The AUM fee is 0.00%, and your broker's costs are separate. There's more in What does Autopilot cost?.
I'm not telling you either one costs less, because it depends on your balance. A percentage rises as your account does, and a flat subscription stays put. Turn each into dollars a year at your balance and compare.
6) Side by side
Who picks the investments
Robo-advisorAn algorithm, working from the questionnaire
Following a Pilot on AutopilotYou pick a Portfolio, and its method decides the holdings
Where the money sits
Robo-advisorVaries by company, so ask
Following a Pilot on AutopilotIn your brokerage account, since Autopilot doesn't hold client money
How you pay
Robo-advisorA percentage or a subscription, per each company's page
Following a Pilot on AutopilotNothing from Autopilot on Basic Tier. On Premium Tier, a flat subscription per Pilot and a 0.00% AUM fee
Minimum to start
Robo-advisorVaries. Betterment lists none for its base price, and Wealthfront says as little as $500
Following a Pilot on Autopilot$500 per Portfolio
What you control
Robo-advisorYour answers, and at some companies the allocation
Following a Pilot on AutopilotThe Portfolio, the dollar amount, and when you stop
Scroll sideways to see every column.
| Robo-advisor | Following a Pilot on Autopilot | |
|---|---|---|
| Who picks the investments | An algorithm, working from the questionnaire | You pick a Portfolio, and its method decides the holdings |
| Where the money sits | Varies by company, so ask | In your brokerage account, since Autopilot doesn't hold client money |
| How you pay | A percentage or a subscription, per each company's page | Nothing from Autopilot on Basic Tier. On Premium Tier, a flat subscription per Pilot and a 0.00% AUM fee |
| Minimum to start | Varies. Betterment lists none for its base price, and Wealthfront says as little as $500 | $500 per Portfolio |
| What you control | Your answers, and at some companies the allocation | The Portfolio, the dollar amount, and when you stop |
7) Features and tradeoffs
Some robo-advisors list features. Wealthfront's page lists automatic rebalancing and tax-loss harvesting. Investor.gov says tax-loss harvesting involves selling investments that have losses, and that its value depends on your tax situation.
Following works a little differently. You're never trading at the same moment as the Portfolio, so your holdings will drift from it a bit. Trades in a taxable brokerage account can create taxable gains or losses, and a tax professional can tell you what that means for you. The IRS explains how capital gains and losses are taxed.
Some brokers make you approve each trade yourself. Where your broker allows it, Premium Tier sends it the orders when the Portfolio changes. Basic Tier sends you an alert instead, and you make the change.
8) Which one fits
If you want to choose the strategy, read its record on a live chart first, and keep your own brokerage account, Autopilot fits. If you'd rather answer a few questions and let a default mix get chosen for you, a robo-advisor fits. Both are reasonable.
You don't have to pick one. If you already have a robo-advisor, following a Portfolio is its own decision, and it happens in a different account.
Don't mistake this for a shortcut to getting rich. A Portfolio can climb for years, stall for years, or lose money. So look into the person and the Portfolio before you put money in. The guide to choosing who to follow shows how.
9) Trying it next to your robo-advisor
- Leave the robo-advisor account exactly as it is.
- Download the Autopilot app and connect an individual or IRA account you already hold at one of its brokers.
- Open a Portfolio's performance chart and read how its method works.
- Allocate at least $500 to it.
TLDR: A robo-advisor builds a portfolio from your questionnaire answers, often out of ETFs, and charges a percentage or a subscription. On Autopilot you choose the Portfolio, your money stays in your own brokerage account, and Autopilot Advisers sends the orders. Nothing from Autopilot on Basic Tier, and Premium Tier is a flat subscription per Pilot with a 0.00% AUM fee. A stock Portfolio can be more concentrated than a fund mix. Work out dollars a year at your balance for both, and read a Portfolio's chart before you follow it.
Frequently asked questions
What's the difference between a robo-advisor and following an investor?
A robo-advisor builds a portfolio from your questionnaire answers. When you follow a Portfolio on Autopilot, you choose it, and a Pilot's picks, an AI model, or public filings decide what it holds. You're never trading at the same moment as the Portfolio, so your account will differ a little. Your money stays in your brokerage account, and each Portfolio has a live performance chart to read first.
Should I use a robo-advisor or pick my own investments?
It depends on how much you want to decide. A robo-advisor decides the mix from your answers. Picking your own investments puts every choice on you, and the SEC's beginners' guide on Investor.gov says you'd need at least a dozen carefully selected stocks to be diversified. Following a Portfolio sits in between: you choose the Portfolio, and its method chooses the holdings.
Robo-advisor vs following a Portfolio
Many robo-advisors build a mix of ETFs from your questionnaire answers for a percentage or a subscription. Following a Portfolio on Autopilot happens in your own brokerage account, with nothing from Autopilot on Basic Tier and a flat subscription per Pilot on Premium Tier. Portfolios can be more concentrated, so read the holdings first.
How do robo-advisor fees compare to a flat subscription?
A percentage fee rises with your balance, and a flat subscription doesn't. As of November 10, 2026, Wealthfront publishes 0.25% a year. Autopilot Premium Tier is $99.99 to $699.99 a year per Pilot, as of October 9, 2026, with a 0.00% AUM fee, so your balance doesn't change it. Which costs less depends on your balance, so convert both to dollars a year first.
Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=robo-advisor-vs-following-a-pilot&af_sub1=end
"Autopilot" refers to Autopilot Holdings Corp and Autopilot Advisers, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. Betterment, Wealthfront, and Stash are separate companies unaffiliated with Autopilot. Open to the Public Investing, Inc., Robinhood Financial LLC, eToro USA Securities Inc., Alpaca Securities LLC, Charles Schwab & Co., Inc., and Interactive Brokers LLC are each a registered broker-dealer and member SIPC, and separate companies unaffiliated with Autopilot. Investing carries risk-including possible loss of principal-and past performance is not indicative of future results. Figures current as of 10/09/26. View our Customer Relationship Summary and other important info at joinautopilot.com/disclaimer.
- Month
- +0.16%
- 3 months
- +1.1%
- YTD
- +12.3%
- 1 year
- +12.8%
- Since start
- +87.5%
As of
- Month
- -0.46%
- 3 months
- -1.7%
- YTD
- +13.9%
- 1 year
- +21.5%
- Since start
- +120.0%
As of
The performance data presented reflects the aggregated results of actual client portfolios managed by the Registered Investment Adviser (RIA), based on the trading activity in the securities contained in the relevant portfolio over the specified period. If fewer than 10 clients are invested in the portfolio, the data represents the aggregate performance of all clients following this strategy. Performance figures are shown net of advisory fees, calculated using the applicable subscription fee and an assumed $50,000 account size. Because subscription fees are flat rather than asset-based, accounts smaller than $50,000 would experience a higher effective fee percentage and lower net performance, while larger accounts would experience a lower effective fee percentage. Actual investor outcomes can vary due to factors like brokerage support for fractional shares, account size, trade timing, fees, and taxes, and past performance should not be interpreted as a guarantee of future results or typical of all portfolios.