Pilot interviews
Zack Fincher: 'Nostalgia takes time'
Zack Fincher, a former stockbroker, on trading collectibles as a teenager, the nostalgia theme behind Long Nostalgia, and holding with conviction.
Zack Fincher's first market was Counter-Strike weapon skins, traded at about 14, and from there came crypto, digital art and NFTs. Zack also spent years in brokerage, placing trades for retail clients and then working with trust and estate clients at Morgan Stanley.
Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=zack-fincher-interview&af_sub1=intro
Zack now runs an investment partnership and publishes two Portfolios on Autopilot: Cruise Control - Retirement and Long Nostalgia. Most of our conversation was about Long Nostalgia, which bets on the brands and collectibles people grew up with and on the marketplaces that take a cut when they change hands.
This interview comes from the transcript of our conversation with Zack Fincher in June 2026. It has been edited and condensed.
What were you doing day to day, and what did you learn?
I worked directly with retail clients. We were placing trades, devising strategies or doing account maintenance. I worked with just about every type of trader, retail client possible. So I learned a lot just about what actually moves markets: narratives, story.
At Morgan Stanley, my role was as a client relationship manager. I worked directly with clients through the estates process, so trusts or legal estates. I worked with them for account maintenance and estate processing, so a lot of legal and trust work over there at Morgan Stanley.
What have you taken from your experience in finance and wealth to your investing now?
A lot of the lessons that I learned were how the back end of a lot of these investment companies work, the knowledge that the average person has going into these things, how these companies actually make money, and that there was a huge opportunity to serve the underserved kind of person that has maybe not a million dollars to their name, who has less than 25K but still wants financial tools and education. So it's an underserved market, and something Autopilot, I think, really serves. So that's why I'm here today.
What did you collect growing up, and what made this feel real for you?
I actually grew up playing and collecting Counter-Strike skins, weapon skins. That was probably the first market I ever traded, just there on Steam and secondary platforms. I was probably 14 at the time, so it was the first market experience I ever had. For me, that was my introduction into a collectibles market, and it also kind of showed me the growth and value something most people wouldn't even say was real could have, so it was pretty cool.
From there I ended up getting into crypto. It was one of the only ways you could actually cash out back in the day, and that led me down a whole other rabbit hole of different versions of digital collectibles, such as digital art and NFTs.
When did you realize nostalgia was a real investable asset class?
I probably first thought about the idea of nostalgia as investable a couple of years ago. It was watching the cryptocurrency space. The industry had kind of a peak, and after that peak, there was a drawdown and a trough. And in that trough, I was watching the space kind of build back, and it wasn't building back the same way. In that build back, there was a huge focus on real world assets, bringing actual stocks, equities, and physical assets such as gold, silver and collectibles on chain.
At first, I lumped them all into one category. But the asset out of those that actually grew the most was the collectibles. It was a lot easier to sell a digital version of a physical collectible than it was a bar of gold. I saw just a huge demand for this kind of digital reintroduction of the collectible space, and it was something I really started to look at and see where you could get exposure to this theme. And Long Nostalgia is the U.S. public kind of infrastructure for that.
What does it mean to buy the toll booths instead of the toys?
By toll booth, I simply mean someone who is there at the road to take a fee on transactions. So while you may not be actively purchasing a collectible, what we own is something like the marketplace, which will take a cut of a secondary trade. They're simply here to take a share of a growing pot.
Long Nostalgia is an investment position in consumer cyclicals. So these are companies that make money from people actually buying goods or services from these companies. It's not a play on government spending or capital expenditure from an AI build-out. This is companies making and selling goods to actual people, and that's something I don't see going away.
Why do you believe nostalgia is durable and not a fad?
I believe nostalgia is durable because of the fact that things do happen in cycles. Things do come back, and the emotional attachment we have to the better years of our life, it's the human condition. That's the reason I think it's durable. I think it's proven in some of the numbers, like the vinyl sales, where people really will spend money to go back and relive their childhood in a way.
Something I wouldn't bet on in the theme of nostalgia is probably short-term trends. Something new, or something that's a fad, that maybe popped up, got popular for a year. There's a lot of blind boxes. I think nostalgia takes time. There needs to be a long track record of these things working, selling, and providing multiple generations of attachment. Something you grew up with and your kid is also growing up with is something I think needs to happen before you could really classify it as nostalgia. Anything on the trendy side I would at least steer away from, at least in terms of a thematic exposure.
How do you research the business behind collectibles and nostalgia?
Understanding the economics behind these companies has changed for me. AI has been a huge help in terms of research and actual scanning of financials. Things that I like to look out for: the growth on secondary markets. I think the secondary sales of some of these products is a huge tell on demand and how much pricing power some of these companies actually have.
What could actually break this thesis?
I think the thesis could be broken in times of terrible economic conditions. Obviously you won't be purchasing from some of these companies. Entertainment may not be a priority. But that could be said with any industry. Something more specific to this industry is the speculative side. Economics could be fine, but in a less speculative environment, some of these may not produce the growth that they're currently experiencing in this bubble-ish environment.
I don't know if it would necessarily be a hedge to the market bubble in general. A lot of times the actual bubble itself fuels a lot of the speculation and craze around some of these products. So I think it is something that actually actively benefits from a bubble. The idea is, post-bubble, you will still have the emotional attachment to some of these things, where you may still spend money in some of these categories even if you are hurting in your pocket. So I don't think it is necessarily a hedge to a bubble. I think it is perhaps a different way to play the bubble.
What is your edge?
I think my edge is having the ability to hold things for a long time with high conviction. How I come to that conviction can vary. I think each trade is different. I don't think there's a framework or a set of rules you can necessarily follow to enter a trade. I think it can work for exiting a trade, but it's going to be different every time. Really, my edge isn't being a genius or anything, but having the ability to hold longer than most people and size accordingly.
You're younger than many people who run strategies; why is that an advantage and not a disadvantage?
I think being young is an advantage. One of the biggest edges you have being young is time. You're allowed to make mistakes, learn from those mistakes, and also experiment, something someone older may not be willing to do. For me, I'm incredibly experimental. It's why I'm here. It's why I do what I do, and I think that gives me an edge. I'm willing to take risks other older money managers may not be willing to take.
What did you learn at Morgan Stanley watching how high-net-worth families invest?
At Morgan Stanley I had a ton of experience working with high-net-worth individuals. Their investments were always non-emotional. These were positions they took with high conviction. They were positions that they were willing to hold for extremely long periods of time, and they had high conviction that they built themselves. It was a thesis that they came up with themselves and had huge belief in.
“"The edge for Long Nostalgia is owning a piece of the emotional attachment and cultural memory that people have."”
Follow Zack Fincher's Portfolios on Autopilot
Zack Fincher publishes Cruise Control - Retirement and Long Nostalgia on Autopilot, an investing app that lets you follow Portfolios from investors, AI models, and public filings in your own brokerage account. See the Zack Fincher Pilot page for the full list. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=zack-fincher-interview&af_sub1=body
- You follow in the brokerage account you already have, and the money stays there.
- On Premium Tier, when the Portfolio changes, Autopilot Advisers sends the orders to your broker. On Basic Tier you get an alert.
- Review the Portfolio's method, holdings and any available performance record before following it. New Portfolios show return figures after 30 days.
- The Pilot sets the subscription price, there's a 0.00% AUM fee, and you allocate at least $500.
You're never trading at the same moment as the Pilot, and your account won't match the Portfolio exactly.
Open it in the Autopilot app. https://link.joinautopilot.com/eXKr?c=zack-fincher-interview&af_sub1=end
"Autopilot" refers to Autopilot Holdings Corp and Autopilot Advisers, LLC, an SEC-registered investment adviser. Cruise Control - Retirement and Long Nostalgia are managed by Zack Fincher, an independent Third-Party Pilot unaffiliated with Autopilot. Autopilot doesn't manage, validate, or guarantee this Pilot's portfolio. This interview reflects Zack's own views as of June 2026, edited and condensed, and isn't a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to follow any Portfolio. Strategies linked to digital assets carry extreme volatility and risk of substantial loss; holding equities or funds exposed to digital assets is not the same as holding those assets. Concentrated and thematic strategies carry heightened risk of loss. Where a Pilot uses an AI tool in their own stock-selection process, that tool does not advise clients, select investments for clients, or place trades. Investing carries risk-including possible loss of principal-and past performance is not indicative of future results. Figures current as of 10/09/26. View our Customer Relationship Summary and other important info at joinautopilot.com/disclaimer.
- Month
- +6.7%
- 3 months
- +7.5%
- YTD
- n/a
- 1 year
- n/a
- Since start
- +13.8%
As of
- Since start
- -3.8%
As of
The performance data presented reflects the aggregated results of actual client portfolios managed by the Registered Investment Adviser (RIA), based on the trading activity in the securities contained in the relevant portfolio over the specified period. If fewer than 10 clients are invested in the portfolio, the data represents the aggregate performance of all clients following this strategy. Performance figures are shown net of advisory fees, calculated using the applicable subscription fee and an assumed $50,000 account size. Because subscription fees are flat rather than asset-based, accounts smaller than $50,000 would experience a higher effective fee percentage and lower net performance, while larger accounts would experience a lower effective fee percentage. Actual investor outcomes can vary due to factors like brokerage support for fractional shares, account size, trade timing, fees, and taxes, and past performance should not be interpreted as a guarantee of future results or typical of all portfolios.